Critiques of Guiding Principles by Amnesty Intl., Human Rights Watch, FIDH, others - debate with Ruggie
On 22 November 2010, UN Special Representative on business & human rights John Ruggie proposed draft "Guiding Principles for the Implementation of the United Nations 'Protect, Respect and Remedy' Framework", and launched a consultation on the Guiding Principles to which all stakeholders could submit comments.
- Draft report by Special Representative Ruggie with full text of Guiding Principles & commentaries [PDF]
The consultation received over 100 submissions (all available here), positive and negative, including many from NGOs. Among them, Amnesty International, CIDSE, ESCR-Net, Human Rights Watch, International Commission of Jurists, International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH) and Rights and Accountability in Development (RAID) made a joint submission:
"Joint Civil Society Statement on the draft Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights" [PDF], 14 Jan 2011
This submission garnered coverage in the Financial Times: "Rights groups slam UN plan for multinationals", Hugh Williamson, 17 Jan 2011. Ruggie responded with this letter [PDF], 17 Jan 2011. Amnesty International and FIDH then issued rejoinders:
Amnesty Intl. response to John Ruggie, 20 Jan 2011
Sir Mark Moody-Stuart and Stéphane Brabant of the law firm Herbert Smith made statements supportive of Ruggie in response to the NGO statement:
Human Rights Watch, Ruggie and Amnesty Intl. UK then engaged in this exchange:
John Ruggie response to Human Rights Watch [PDF], 28 Jan 2011
Response [PDF] by Peter Frankental, Amnesty UK, to Ruggie's 28 Jan statement, 4 Feb 2011
Related stories and components
Author: Arvind Ganesan, Director, Business and Human Rights, Human Rights Watch, in letter to Financial Times
Sir, John Ruggie’s response to Hugh Williamson’s article “Amnesty criticises UN framework for multinationals” mischaracterises our views. Human rights organisations submitted comments to improve the proposed draft of guiding principles so that they...
Author: Widney Brown, Senior Director for International Law and Policy, Amnesty International
Sir, John Ruggie’s letter (January 19) in response to Hugh Williamson’s article “Amnesty criticises UN framework for multinationals” (January 17) is surprising on several counts...Let’s be frank – the real opposition to effective guiding principles...
Author: International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH)
Sir, The International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH) is surprised by your interpretation of the NGOs' joint statement co-signed by FIDH on the draft Guiding Principles as well as Professor Ruggie's response to your article. While you do point out...