Lesotho garment workers struck landmark deals to tackle gender-based violence. Here's how it happened
13/9/10 - Rola Abimourched, Libakiso Matlho, Thusoana Ntlama & Robin Runge
Experts detail the road to these agreements, how they will work, and what it means for future efforts to protect and empower women workers
Gender-based violence and harassment, including sexual harassment in the world of work, are among the most pervasive human rights violations and most effective tools at preventing gender equality.
Female garment workers—who are the majority of the global garment workforce—are systematically targeted and experience the highest rates of sexual harassment and gender-based violence at work. Gender-based violence is especially severe in workplaces where the gender-based power imbalance is greatest and where workers have a limited ability to advocate for their rights, such as the garment sector.
Recognizing the limitations of employer-led efforts to address sexual harassment through trainings and policies, trade unions and women’s rights advocates in Lesotho came together to negotiate a new program to prevent and address gender-based violence and harassment by addressing their root causes with accountability at its core.
August 15, 2019, saw the fruition of these efforts with a set of landmark agreements among leading apparel brands, a coalition of labor unions and women’s rights advocates, and a major apparel supplier to combat gender-based violence and harassment in Lesotho’s garment sector.
The five Lesotho trade unions and women’s rights organizations - Independent Democratic Union of Lesotho (IDUL), United Textile Employees (UNITE), the National Clothing Textile and Allied Workers Union, the Federation of Women Lawyers in Lesotho (FIDA) and Women and Law in Southern African Research and Education Trust-Lesotho (WLSA) - signed separate enforceable agreements with Levi Strauss & Co., The Children’s Place, and Kontoor Brands (Wrangler and Lee jeans).
What are the deals?
The agreements condition these brands’ business with the supplier, Nien Hsing Textile Co., on its cooperation with a worker-led programme to eliminate gender-based violence and harassment in the garment factories in Lesotho that produce their clothes.
The two US-based NGOs and one trade union - the Solidarity Center, the Worker Rights Consortium (WRC), and Workers United - who assisted with the negotiations are non-party signatories to these agreements. The Solidarity Center will lead in assisting the parties involved in implementation of the programme.
The agreements signed with the brands will operate in tandem with a separate agreement between Nien Hsing and the trade unions and women’s rights organizations in Lesotho to establish an independent investigative organization responsible for investigating allegations of gender-based violence and harassment at Nien Hsing’s Lesotho factories.
If it determines the code of conduct has been violated, the organization will direct specific remedies up to and including dismissal of the manager or worker responsible.
Representatives from the unions and women’s groups met with representatives of the Coalition for Immokalee Workers and gained inspiration from the organization Fair Food Program, which has been remarkably successful in eradicating sexual harassment and coercion in Florida’s agricultural fields - one of the world’s toughest labor rights environments.
In stark contrast to internal factory complaint mechanisms, this programme will provide workers with a safe channel for reporting incidents of gender-based violence and harassment with the goal of increasing reports and limiting retaliation.
The programme also provides an information and complaint line run by the women’s rights organizations in Lesotho, providing legal aid and counseling services to workers and an extensive worker-to-worker training scheme, and related education and awareness activities.
Defining the problem
In June 2019, the International Labor Organization (ILO) adopted a global convention to end violence and harassment in the world of work which is binding on member governments, employers and workers’ rights organizations (ILO Convention 190). The international treaty specifically defined gender-based violence and harassment including sexual harassment in the world of work, and the need for employers, governments and worker organizations to address the gendered nature of violence and harassment.
The definition of gender-based violence and harassment included in the agreement among Nien Hsing, the trade unions and women’s rights groups was modeled after best practices that union women identified and advocated for incorporation into the global convention and represents the first time that this term has been used in a legally binding tool to address these forms of abuse in the workplace, and is consistent with the definition contained in ILO Convention 190.
The agreement also protects associational rights by prohibiting any form of anti-union retaliation or interference with workers’ exercise of their right to organize.
This is crucial because it is impossible to prevent and address gender-based violence and harassment in the workplace without freedom of association. Workers’ ability to act collectively to protect their rights and interests is an essential tool to effectively change the gender-based power inequality that increases the risk of gender-based violence and harassment.
Previously, restrictions on the ability of workers at the Nien Hsing factories in Lesotho to exercise their right to collective action was a major contributing factor to the high incidence of gender-based violence and harassment at these facilities.
How did we get here?
These agreements arose from an investigation conducted by the WRC, which exposed severe and extensive sexual harassment and coercion affecting 10,000 workers employed at Nien Hsing’s garment factories in Lesotho.
A measure of the pervasiveness of gender-based violence and harassment at the factories is that nearly two-thirds of the women workers with whom the WRC conducted in-depth interviews reported having experienced sexual harassment or abuse or having contemporaneous knowledge of harassment or abuse suffered by co-workers.
Women workers’ vulnerability to abuse is further exacerbated by the power supervisors and managers exert on workers’ continued employment, as well as their conditions of work. Workers who chose to report abuses typically faced retaliation.
These agreements will aim to change the culture of fear and impunity that previously existed in these factories, where the brands’ voluntary codes of conduct and social audits were relied upon to monitor labor conditions.
As outlined in the WRC’s report, the brands sourcing from Nien Hsing’s Lesotho factories did not detect gender-based violence and harassment via their voluntary codes of conduct and monitoring programs, which allowed the abuses to continue.
Further, workers, in offsite interviews, testified that Nien Hsing managers concealed the actual conditions and treatment of workers from brand auditors, including by pressuring employees not to tell the truth about their conditions of work to brand representatives who visited the factory.
Thus, workers’ only option to report these abuses was the internal grievance mechanism of the factory, which essentially entailed asking workers to trust the very management responsible for the abuses.
A new approach
The approach to engaging brands, factory owners, unions and women’s rights groups together to address the root causes of gender-based violence and harassment, including gender inequality and unequal power relations between men and women, contained in these binding and enforceable agreements present a fundamentally different approach.
Collectively, they have the power to hold perpetrators accountable and give workers access to meaningful remedies through the creation of an independent organization to investigate gender-based violence and determine remedies. Beyond Lesotho, these agreements set a vital precedent in the fight against gender-based violence and harassment in the world of work.
Rola Abimourched is the Senior Program Director at the Worker Rights Consortium where she leads the organization’s work in Lesotho.
Libakiso Matlho is a Gender and Human Rights Activist, Researcher and Director of Women and Law in Southern African Research and Education Trust-Lesotho.
Thusoana Ntlama is Programme Coordinator at Federation of Women Lawyers in Lesotho, she represented her organization during the negotiations to establish a program to prevent and eliminate gender-based violence at the Nien Hsing factories.
Robin Runge is the Acting Director and Senior Gender Specialist in the Equality and Inclusion Department at the Solidarity Center where she leads the organization's campaign to end gender-based violence in the world of work.