Lincoln Electric ordered to pay welder sickened by fumes $17.5 million [USA]

Author: Damian Guevara, Cleveland Plain Dealer [USA], Published on: 6 December 2007

A federal jury in Cleveland on Wednesday ordered Euclid-based Lincoln Electric Holdings and four other companies to pay $17.5 million to a welder who claims he got sick from the fumes he inhaled... The nine-person jury in U.S. District Court in Cleveland found that Lincoln Electric, Hobart Brothers Co. [part of Illinois Tool Works], ESAB Group [part of Charter], TDY Industries [part of Allegheny Technologies] and BOC Group [part of Linde] showed negligence by not warning Jeff Tamraz of the toxicity of manganese in their products... Plaintiffs in the welding cases claim that the ultra-fine manganese particles in welding fumes...cause damage that results in tremors. Medical studies attempting to determine whether there is such a cause-and-effect relationship have been mostly inconclusive. The welding companies have said that the amount of manganese in welding fumes is too low to cause harm...

Read the full post here

Related companies: Allegheny Technologies BOC Group (part of Linde) Charter ESAB (part of Charter) Hobart Brothers (part of Illinois Tool Works) Illinois Tool Works Lincoln Electric Linde Group