Dutch Govt. to renegotiate tax treaties with 23 developing countries in response to criticisms of facilitating corporate tax avoidance
All components of this story
Author: SOMO (Centre for Research on Multinational Corporations)
After years of social pressure, the Dutch government recently admitted...that its tax policy, including tax treaty policy, is harmful to many people, countries and companies worldwide. SOMO has played an important role in recent years by publishing numerous reports about tax avoidance...Studies by SOMO have shown that large multinationals establish so-called “mailbox” companies in the Netherlands and use them to channel payments to tax havens...[T]he money that flows through these companies results in a direct loss of tax revenue for other countries, especially developing countries, which lose billions of Euros...The Ministries of Finance and Development Cooperation have announced they will join forces to reduce tax avoidance in the Netherlands...Whether government proposals for a fairer tax system will succeed will depend on the way the measures are implemented and enforced. Yet SOMO is excited about the current impact of its investigations.
Author: Matt Steinglass & Jamie Smyth, Financial Times (UK)
A Dutch initiative to crack down on tax avoidance by multinational corporations is being fiercely resisted by the business community, with the American Chamber of Commerce in the Netherlands warning it could drive US corporations to move their European headquarters out of the country...This month the Netherlands responded to rising criticism with a plan to tighten conditions for so-called letterbox companies, shell companies that multinationals establish largely for tax purposes. The proposal includes an offer to renegotiate Dutch tax treaties with 23 developing countries, which tax justice advocates say lose out on huge amounts of revenue through tax avoidance...Wouter Paardekooper, a partner at Baker & McKenzie who heads the tax committee of American group, said the new plan introduces uncertainty that will hurt the Dutch investment climate. “There are companies with major regional headquarters here with investments in Africa,” Mr Paardekooper said. “[Their] consideration as to whether we should go ahead in the Netherlands, or should make future investments somewhere else, is not well served by this [offer].”
Author: Matt Steinglass, Financial Times (UK)
A proposal by the Netherlands to renegotiate its tax treaties with 23 least-developed countries marks a turning point for a country that has until now deflected accusations that it is a key player in tax avoidance by multinational corporations...The Dutch move stems from a government-commissioned report over the summer which, for the first time, agreed with tax-justice groups that developing countries miss out on substantial tax revenues because of their treaties with the Netherlands...The Dutch propose to insert new anti-fraud provisions in the tax treaties...In a second move, the Dutch will pass on information to tax inspectors in least-developed countries when multinationals request a so-called “tax ruling” in the Netherlands...[T]he Dutch will crack down on letterbox companies by forcing even companies that have not asked for tax rulings to meet the country’s “substance demands”...Advocacy groups in the Netherlands have cautiously applauded the Dutch move, but said the new measures were modest.
Author: compiled by Business & Human Rights Resource Centre
- Related stories: ActionAid launches new guide for investors on how to seek a responsible approach to corporate tax Australia will require multinationals to disclose tax arrangements in effort to curb alleged tax avoidance Barclays' "tax avoidance division" generated more than £1 billion a year according to review commissioned by company Briefing discusses tax avoidance as a business ethics issue Call to contribute to report on fiscal & tax policy by UN Special Rapporteur on extreme poverty and human rights Comment: EU plans to make large companies disclose taxes & profits on a country-by-country basis will increase transparency on tax avoidance Commentary on corporate tax avoidance & changing attitudes of govts. to regulation Conference: "Tax Justice - A Human Rights Issue?" (Johannesburg, 21 Nov) Dutch Govt. to renegotiate tax treaties with 23 developing countries in response to criticisms of facilitating corporate tax avoidance European Council leaders commit to tackle tax evasion at summit Fair Tax Mark launches world's 1st independent tax accreditation scheme France: UBS under investigation for allegedly facilitating tax avoidance; company says it is fully cooperating with authorities G20 finance ministers back OECD plans to tackle corporate tax avoidance Ghana to table mining windfall tax bill to parliament Global Financial Integrity director explains why illicit financial flows are a human rights issue Google branded "devious" over UK tax arrangements by Commons public accounts committee Head of Ireland's Catholic church urges G8 to tackle tax avoidance & says "paying a fair share of taxes" is a "moral obligation" Indian tax authorities accuse Cadbury of avoiding $46 million in taxes; parent company says it is fully cooperating with investigation Intl. Bar Association Human Rights Institute's report addresses tax abuse from poverty & human rights law perspectives Italy: Dolce & Gabbana founders sentenced to prison & heavy fine for tax evasion over sale of company that avoided tax on royalties; designers to appeal ruling Liberian government takes Lonestar to court alleging company liable for $19mil in taxes Mexico: Seven multinational companies investigated over allegedly avoiding paying taxes NGOs call on UK Govt. to increase transparency of company ownership to fight tax avoidance & ensure govts. can provide essential public services OECD releases new single global standard on automatic exchange of financial account information to tackle tax avoidance OECD releases set of actions to modernise intl. tax system & crackdown on corporate tax avoidance Parliamentarian says "illicit transfers" by corporations denying Tanzanians chance to improve infrastructure, education & health services Process of pragmatic inquiry & consensus building on corporate & govt. responsibilities in taxation needed for informed public debate, analyst says Report accuses Energias de Portugal (EDP) of tax avoidance through investments in Netherlands Save the Children report calls on govts. & businesses to tackle tax evasion to prevent child mortality Study says 26 companies paid more to CEOs than they did in US taxes Tax Justice: A Human Rights Issue? [Johannesburg, 21 Nov] UK court exposes attempt to avoid tax on intl. ports business by Dubai-owned DP World UK Govt. reportedly ready to back plans to force all European companies to reveal where they pay tax UK Govt. to exclude companies found guilty of aggressive tax avoidance from bidding for major govt. contracts UK Govt. to make public registry of company owners to combat corporate tax avoidance, following NGOs' campaign UK, Germany & France call on G20 to curb tax avoidance by companies UK: Barclays closes controversial tax avoidance unit UK: Chair of Public Accounts Committee says new tax laws too heavily influenced by large corporations & accountancy firms UK: Google called back to parliament to answer tax questions after investigation challenges some of its previous evidence; company denies claims UK: Google CEO defends company's tax affairs; firm was accused of "immorally" minimising tax obligations by Public Accounts Committee UK: House of Lords sub-committee says proposed tax avoidance legislation is "narrowly defined" & calls to accelerate OECD review of multinationals' taxation UK: Independent booksellers deliver petition with 150,000 signatures asking Prime Minister to make Amazon pay corporation tax UK: Labour would stop "scandalous" company tax avoidance, says party leader Ed Miliband UK: MPs ready to "haul Amazon back to parliament" for questions after investigation suggests it is "pushing the tax rulebook to its limits" - includes company comments UK: One third of Britons polled boycott companies due to tax avoidance, says Christian Aid UK: Public Accounts Committee says Deloitte, Ernst & Young, KPMG & PWC are using knowledge gained from staff seconded to the Treasury to help clients avoid tax UK: Starbucks pays £5 million in corporation tax following pressure from tax avoidance campaigners UK: Wonga accused of attempting to avoid tax by shifting part of business to Switzerland; payday lender denies claims US companies accused of having many subsidiaries in Ireland to benefit from lower tax rate than US USA: Apple under scrutiny for tax avoidance; change in tax system & customer attitudes may be needed to curtail practice, says commentary USA: Google goes to court to claim tax back, despite being under scrutiny for tax avoidance USA: Senators accuse Apple of "highly questionable" billion-dollar tax avoidance scheme - includes company comments Show moreShow less