S. Africa: Civil Society wants environmental authorisation of gas power plant set aside for lack of proper public participation process by Eskom
‘Civil society in court to challenge gas power plant in Richards Bay’ 27 July 2022
The South Durban Community Environmental Alliance (SDCEA) and groundWork will be in the Pretoria High Court next week to ask the court to set aside the environmental authorisation granted to Eskom for the construction of a combined cycle power plant in Richards Bay. This landmark litigation marks the first time that a gas-to-power plant has been challenged in a court in South Africa. SDCEA and groundWork are supported by Natural Justice and Green Connection, and represented by environmental law firm, Cullinan & Associates. Eskom Holdings SOC, a state-owned enterprise, was granted environmental authorisation in December 2019, although construction on the project has not yet begun. The gas-to-power plant will be fuelled by gas via a pipeline that will be installed from the Richards Bay Port and will supply up to 3000MW of energy.
In their court papers, SDCEA and groundWork have called for the environmental authorisation to be declared unlawful and set aside based on inadequacies within the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) and due to the public participation process, that was undertaken being flawed. In the Earthlife Africa judgment handed down in 2017, the Constitutional Court stated that climate change impacts must be assessed before issuing an environmental authorisation for a proposed project. In the current case, SDCEA and groundWork argue that there was an inadequate assessment of the climate change impacts of the project. Evidence shows that a gas power plant, such as the proposed plant, emits as many greenhouse gasses as other fossil fuels, like coal, during the entire life-cycle of a project.
The public participation process for this development was flawed, as many communities were excluded from the public participation process. These included traditional communities in surrounding rural areas. The information about the project was also advertised exclusively in English despite the EIA Report itself recognising that 79% of the population of uMhlathuze Municipality, where Richards Bay is situated, speak isiZulu. The case will be heard in the Pretoria High Court on 2 and 3 August 2022.