abusesaffiliationarrow-downarrow-leftarrow-rightarrow-upattack-typeburgerchevron-downchevron-leftchevron-rightchevron-upClock iconclosedeletedevelopment-povertydiscriminationdollardownloademailenvironmentexternal-linkfacebookfiltergenderglobegroupshealthC4067174-3DD9-4B9E-AD64-284FDAAE6338@1xinformation-outlineinformationinstagraminvestment-trade-globalisationissueslabourlanguagesShapeCombined Shapeline, chart, up, arrow, graphLinkedInlocationmap-pinminusnewsorganisationotheroverviewpluspreviewArtboard 185profilerefreshIconnewssearchsecurityPathStock downStock steadyStock uptagticktooltiptwitteruniversalityweb

이 페이지는 한국어로 제공되지 않으며 English로 표시됩니다.

이 내용은 다음 언어로도 제공됩니다: English, Português, 简体中文, 繁體中文

브리핑

11 12월 2024

Stop and listen: Pathways to meaningful engagement with rightsholders in the global rush to mine for transition minerals

Shutterstock (licensed)

The urgency to fight the climate crisis is driving a global scramble to extract the transition minerals required to power vast solar operations, wind farms, and transport electrification at enormous scale.

The mining sector has a well-known history of human rights and environmental abuse: the Resource Centre has tracked 630 such allegations in transition mineral mining operations since 2010. At the same time, the extractive sector has long been the most dangerous for human rights defenders (HRDs).

This should raise alarm as the new mining boom comes with significant threat: cutting corners on social and environmental safeguards to accelerate mining licensing and permitting frameworks, predicated on the false logic that engaging communities and identifying environmental risks will slow down project development rather than ensure viability and sustainability.

Through case studies and analysis, this report demonstrates that failure to meaningfully engage rightsholders can lead to social unrest, conflicts, litigation and significant financial consequences for companies and investors – all threats to the swift energy transition on which fighting the climate crisis depends. On the other hand, corporate commitment to “meaningful engagement” can underpin an energy transition that is fast because it is fair: in other words, built on fair negotiations and true access to information; respect for human and environmental rights; and commitment to shared prosperity with mining-affected communities. 

What is meaningful engagement? With this report, the Resource Centre analysed three emblematic cases of community engagement to begin to answer this question and highlight risks that the rush to mine transition minerals can pose to community engagement where the right to public participation is not safeguarded: 

  • In Odisha, India, the public consultation for the environmental clearance for the Sijimali Bauxite block, owned by Vedanta Limited, took place in a context in a context of strong rightsholder opposition, and state- backed repression.
  • In Portugal, prosecutors sought annulment of Savannah Resources’ environmental permit for the proposed Covas do Barroso lithium mine based on violations of domestic law and international commitments, given risks to heritage and the environment. This case follows widespread resistance to the mine from the surrounding community in the face of a failure to respect public participation rights: state agencies consistently failed to provide project relevant information.
  • In Brazil in 2023, quilombolas, Indigenous Peoples and other communities brought a public action calling for the licence of the Paragominas bauxite mine pipeline to be revoked on the basis that there are of irregularities in consultation around the licensing process. This follows decades of tensions and conflicts between Mineração Paragominas, the mine's operators and surrounding communities.

Pathways to meaningful engagement require, first and foremost, a clear and robust commitment by producing states to this process, including:

  • State protection of fundamental human rights and civic freedoms, including the right of Indigenous Peoples to free, prior and informed consent (FPIC), respect for public participation rights, as features of and in relation to, rights of freedom of expression, assembly and association. Human rights defenders must be protected and their voices not silenced. Critically, states must refrain from relaxing regulatory standards to expedite mining permitting and licensing processes.
  • Early-stage engagement, led by the state, at a point where rightsholders can still influence decision-making outcomes and decision to mine in particular, and . Engagement should continue throughout the lifecycle of a mine when a decision to mine is reached. States must create space for safe and inclusive dialogue even where – and perhaps particularly where – widespread opposition to mining exists.
  • The process must be underpinned by truly accessible information, clear legal and non-legal avenues to challenge irregularities, and an expanded definition of “project- relevant information”, including over ‘public interest’ clauses or exemptions, as well as the use of newly- extracted minerals in the energy transition.
  • Meaningful engagement from the state should include related information on domestic energy transition policy, including demand reduction, as well as intended end-users for minerals. The energy transition should not be invoked as a justification by states or companies to rush to mining without evidenced substantiation.

Companies themselves, as part of their duty to respect human rights, must also effect meaningful engagement with affected rightsholders. This means adopting robust engagement and due diligence policies which go beyond regulatory compliance requirements - which too often tragically fail to represent the views of the population, Indigenous Peoples, and other communities – where needed.

Companies must take urgent note that even with the apparent backing of the state, they may still remain complicit in, and potentially liable for, human rights abuses.

Public participation rights are human rights that must be protected. They matter because while not every mining project will immediately run roughshod over the interests of rightsholders, many have – and the erosion of regulatory safeguards in the rush to accelerate mining permitting and licensing processes only makes this more likely. Meaningful engagement requires a good-faith effort and a willingness to truly listen to the voices of rightsholders and consider a wide range of outcomes in initial engagement – including their right to say no to mining projects.

See more

Transition Minerals Tracker: 2024 Global Analysis

2010 - 2023 allegations and 2023 trends analysis

"You can't eat lithium": Community consent and access to information in transition mineral mining

Three case studies from Serbia, Spain and the USA demonstrate the community harm, hardening opposition to mining projects, and delays or suspensions that can occur when mining projects lack a social licence to operate.

Powering electric vehicles: Human rights impacts of Indonesia's nickel rush (2024)

This briefing highlights the environmental and human rights abuses tied to nickel mining in Indonesia, crucial for electric vehicle (EV) batteries. It reveals how mining operations, driven by rising EV demand, are causing deforestation, water pollution, and endangering the livelihoods of Indigenous communities.

개인정보

이 웹사이트는 쿠키 및 기타 웹 저장 기술을 사용합니다. 아래에서 개인정보보호 옵션을 설정할 수 있습니다. 변경 사항은 즉시 적용됩니다.

웹 저장소 사용에 대한 자세한 내용은 다음을 참조하세요 데이터 사용 및 쿠키 정책

Strictly necessary storage

ON
OFF

Necessary storage enables core site functionality. This site cannot function without it, so it can only be disabled by changing settings in your browser.

분석 쿠키

ON
OFF

귀하가 우리 웹사이트를 방문하면 Google Analytics를 사용하여 귀하의 방문 정보를 수집합니다. 이 쿠키를 수락하면 저희가 귀하의 방문에 대한 자세한 내용을 이해하고, 정보 표시 방법을 개선할 수 있습니다. 모든 분석 정보는 익명이 보장되며 귀하를 식별하는데 사용하지 않습니다. Google은 모든 브라우저에 대해 Google Analytics 선택 해제 추가 기능을 제공합니다.

프로모션 쿠키

ON
OFF

우리는 소셜미디어와 검색 엔진을 포함한 제3자 플랫폼을 통해 기업과 인권에 대한 뉴스와 업데이트를 제공합니다. 이 쿠키는 이러한 프로모션의 성과를 이해하는데 도움이 됩니다.

이 사이트에 대한 개인정보 공개 범위 선택

이 사이트는 필요한 핵심 기능 이상으로 귀하의 경험을 향상시키기 위해 쿠키 및 기타 웹 저장 기술을 사용합니다.